Hurova Anna, Lustosa Maryna, Mongrolle Zhulien

Yearly journal of scientific articles Pravova derzhava Volume 31 (2020), 293-304.

Hurova Anna, Lustosa Maryna, Mongrolle Zhulien. A new approach to access to environmental information and protection of environmental rights.

The Aarhus Convention concerning the right of information, participation and access to the justice in the environmental field was adopted in 25 June 1998, and came into effect in 30 October 2001 as part of the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (ECE-UN) is open for the adherence for every State even if not located in the European continent. However, in Mars 4, 2018, the Escazú Convention was adopted as a part of the Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC), enshrining the same procedurals rights that Aarhus. The objective of this article is to understand why Latin-American states have chosen to create their own regional convention, even if they could have joined the Aarhus Convention concerning the same rights? The approach used to the making of this article was the bibliographic research et the interpretation of legislation and the conventions. 

In conclusion theres two hypotheses justify the adoption of a certain convention, the Escazú Convention could be the answer of the Latin American towards the effectiveness of the Aarhus Convention, for instance minimization of effective realization of judicial protection of environmental rights and also, the Escazú Convention is the translation of the specific conception of environmental protection in Latin America. 

Also, the study found that States of Latin American and the Caribbean, through preservation of indigenous peoples, are able to transform the concept of sustainable development into so-called "continued development" and "good life" concepts. These concepts are not based on the balance of environmental and economic interests, but on the predominance of the first one. The practical implementation of these ideological foundations must go a long way to being effective, but clear wording of individual legal personality of people in fragile environmental situations, which is expressed in particular at the international level, in our opinion, already, forms the basis for further changes towards saving the planet for future generations.

Key words: Aarhus Convention, Escazú Convention, Effectiveness of Procedural Rights, Environmental Law.

References

1. Convention sur l'accès a l'information, la participation du public au processus décisionnel et l'accès la justice en matière d'environnement. United Nations. URL : https://treaties.un.org/doc/Treaties/1998/06/19980625%2008-35%20AM/Ch_XXVII_13p.pdf. 2. Future, Report of the World Commission on Environment and Development: Our Common. URL : https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/5987our-common-future.pdf. 3. Ministry of Ecology and Natural Resources of Ukraine. Environmental damage in eastern Ukraine and recovery priorities. URL : https://menr.gov.ua/files/images/news/24012018/Environmental%20Damage%20in%20Eastern%20Ukraine%20and%20Recovery%20Priorities.pdf. 4. Marion, Paoletti. Linvention dun nouveau référendum pour résoudre la crise à Notre-Dame-des-Landes . Revue française de droit Constitutionnel. 2017., 2017/1 ( 109), P. 173196; 5. Janin, Patrick. Communication au Comite dexamen du respect. URL : https://www.unece.org/fileadmin/DAM/env/pp/compliance/C2015-135-France/Communication_France_Janin_04.11.2015_fre_Redacted.pdf. 6. Prieur, Michel. LUnion européenne menace la Convention dAarhus sur laccès à la justice en matière denvironnement . Revue juridique de lenvironnement, 2018, 2018/2 (Vol. 43), P. 223225; 7. Truilhé-Marengo, Estelle Brosset et Eve. Laccès au juge dans le domaine de lenvironnement : le hiatus du droit de lunion européenne . Revue des droits et libertés fondamentaux. 2018, chronique n07; 8. Paulo Affonso Leme Machado. L'environnement et la Constitution brésilienne. Cahiers du Conseil constitutionnel (Dossier : Constitution et environnement), janvier 2004, 15; 9. Brésil, Constitution de la République Fédérative du 1988. URL : https://www.wipo.int/edocs/lexdocs/laws/fr/br/br117fr.pdf. 10. Constitution, Argentina's. Oxford University Press, Inc., 1853 with amendments. URL : https://www.constituteproject.org/constitution/Argentina_1994.pdf?lang=en. 11. Los Nuevos Modelos Constitucionales Alternativos Al Desarrollo En América Del Sur (Buen Vivir Y Desarrollo Perdurable En La Arena Del Derecho). Gonzalo, SOZZO. Buenos Aires:, octubre/ diciembre 2014., Revista de Derecho Ambiental, P. 7798. 12. Sólo imaginando otros mundos, se cambiará éste. Reflexiones sobre el Buen Vivir. Plataforma Buen Vivir. el 27 marzo, 2012. URL : http://www.plataformabuenvivir.com/2012/03/acosta-reflexiones-buen-vivir/. 13. Ecuador, Constitucion de 2008 República del. URL : http://pdba.georgetown.edu/Constitutions/Ecuador/english08.html. 14. Acordo Regional sobre Acesso à Informação, Participação Pública e Acesso à Justiça em Assuntos Ambientais na América Latina e no Caribe. 2018. URL : https://repositorio.cepal.org/bitstream/handle/11362/43611/S1800493_pt.pdf.

<<