Yearly journal of scientific articles “Pravova derzhava” Volume 31 (2020), 389-396 p.
Drozdovych Nadiia. Conditions of admissibility of procedural analogy in criminal proceedings in Ukraine
The article deals with the current state of the legislative definition of procedural analogy in the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine and is described the procedural analogy as a means of overcoming the gaps in the statutory regulation. At the same time, is the presentation of the theoretical and forensic and practical aspect of determining the conditions under which a procedural analogy is permissible in criminal proceedings and the conditions under which the application of legal norms by analogy is not allowed are also noted. The theoretical ideas about procedural analogy were also reflected in the case law of the court of cassation examples of which are given in the publication, with the formed legal conclusions on particular issues of application or inadmissibility of application of procedural analogy in criminal proceedings.
Key words: procedural analogy, legislative gaps, conditions of admissibility of procedural analogy, conditions of inadmissible application of procedural analogy.
References
1. Drozdovych N.L. Protsesualna analohiia: samostiinyi pryntsyp kryminalnoho provadzhennia chy element zakonnosti. Slovo Natsionalnoi shkoly suddiv Ukrainy. 2019 ¹ 3 (28). S. 115–126.
2. Ålk³nd P. S. Tolkovan³e ³ pr³menen³e norm uholovno-protsessualnoho prava. M., 1968. S. 127; Strohovych M. S. Pryroda sovetskoho uholovnoho protsessa ³ pr³ntsypy sostiazatelnost³. M., 1939. 152 s.; Pashkevych P. F. Sudebnaia praktyka y uholovnûi protsess. Sudebnaia praktyka v sovetskoi pravovoi systeme. M. : Yur³d. l³t. 1975. 226 s.
3. Vlasenko N. A. Ob analohyy v sovremennom protsessualnom prave. Rossyiskaia yustytsyia. 2005. ¹ 7. S. 36.; Kamynskaia V. Y., Dobrovolskaia T. N. Retsenzyia na knyhu P. S. Ålk³nd. Sovetskoe hosudarstvo y pravo. 1968. ¹ 1. S. 158.
4. Kartashov V. N. Ynstytut analohyy v sovetskom prave (voprosû teoryy): avtoref. ... kand. yuryd. nauk: 12.00. Saratov, 1976. 19 s.
5. Kemularyia Ý. Sh. Problemû prymenenyia uholovno-protsessualnoho zakona po analohyy: dys. ... kand. yuryd. nauk: 12.00.09. M., 1983. 161 s.
6. Iakub M. L. Protsessualnaia forma v sovetskom uholovnom sudoproyzvodstve. M., 1981. 145 s.
7. Strohovych M. S. Kurs sovetskoho uholovnoho protsessa. T. 1 : Osnovnûe polozhenyia nauky sovetskoho uholovnoho protsessa. M. : Nauka, 1968. 468 s.
8. Ålkynd P. S. Sushchnost sovetskoho uholovno-protsessualnoho prava. L., 1963. 171 s.
9. Hrodzynskyi M. M. Analohyia v sovetskom uholovno-protsessualnom prave. Uchenye zap³sk³ Kharkovskoho yur³d. yn-ta. 1948. Vyp. 3. 197 s.
10. Belonosov V. O. Teoryia y praktyka prymenenyia analohyy v uholovnom sudoproyzvodstve: dys. … kand. yuryd. nauk: 12.00.09. Saratov, 1998. 199 s.
11.Kaplina O. Do pytannia pro analohiiu kryminalno-protsesualnoho zakonu. Yurydychna Ukraina. 2005. ¹ 1. S. 55–60.
12. Postanova KKS VS vid 13 hrudnia 2018 r. (sprava ¹ 367/3872/17, provadzhennia ¹ 51-3205km18). URL : http://reyestr.court. gov.ua/Review/77968952
13. Postanova KKS VS vid 4 kvitnia 2019 r. (sprava ¹ 494/6/18, provadzhennia ¹ 51-9701km18). URL : http://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/81013253
<< Íàçàä
